Security Deposit: 1 In 4 Don't Get Back

This is important information for both landlord and tenant.

But the most alarming statistic: 36 percent of respondents said that their landlords offered no explanation at all for why they were withholding security deposits. Well, guess what: That's not always legal. In New York, for example, landlords are required to return security deposits, minus any legal deductions, within a certain period of time. In California, there are only four reasons why a landlord may withhold a security deposit: to cover unpaid rent, to clean the rental when a tenant moves out, to repair damages caused by the renter, or to replace furnishings (only if the lease agreement explicitly states that this is allowable). And a landlord must state the reason to the renter for why his or her security deposit is being withheld. Landlord.com has a list of security deposit laws in all 50 states to help you find the rules where you live.

Read the whole article (opens in a new tab so you may easily comment here): Security Deposit Refund: 1 in 4 Renters Dont Get Their Money Back, Survey Finds | AOL Real Estate. Also read our added comments as follows:

Taking photos is good, but dating them in a way that will stand up in court is the challenge. Put existing damage in writing in the Rental Agreement. A photo of that existing damage will then be an easier sell to the judge or arbiter if it comes to that. Any damage that is there when the tenant is moving out that wasn't itemized in the damage section of the Agreement will then be less a bone of contention between the parties.

If there is a Cleaning Deposit, per se, then the Security Deposit might not necessarily kick in unless there's more than cleaning to do or unless the two deposits and how they can be applied are expressly stated in the Rental Agreement.

A poorly drafted Rental Agreement will usually be ruled against the drafter (who is typically the landlord).

Also, check any Cleaning Deposit or the Security Deposit for just how clean the property must be left to get/give a full or partial refund.

If you are a landlord, make sure your lawyer who drafts your Standard Rental Agreement has E&O Insurance (Errors and Omissions) in case he or she does an unprofessional job that starts costing you way too much money trying to defend.

Be prepared to update your contract documents too. When it comes to new or renewing tenants, use the newer language.


If you are an investor in 1-4 unit properties in Arizona, California, Nevada, Oregon, Utah, or Washington, please do the financially responsible thing and make sure you have proper Landlord Insurance with PropertyPak™. We love focusing on real estate and the economy in general, but we are also here to serve your insurance needs.

Hill & Usher (PropertyPak™ is a division) has many insurance offerings. See our menu above for more info and links.

Did this post help you? Let us know by leaving your comment below.

Note: This blog does not provide legal, financial, or accounting advice. Seek professional counsel.

Furthermore, we, as insurance producers, are prohibited by law from disparaging the insurance industry, carriers, other producers, etc. With that in mind, we provide links without staking out positions that violate the law. We provide them solely from a public-policy standpoint wherein we encourage our industry to be sure our profits, etc., are fair and balanced.

We do not necessarily fact checked the contents of every linked article or page, etc.

If we were to conclude any part or parts of our industry are in violation of fundamental fairness and the legal standards of a state or states, we'd address the issue through proper, legal channels. We trust you understand.

The laws that tie our tongues, so to speak, are designed to keep the public from losing confidence in the industry and the regulatory system overseeing it. Insurance commissioners around the country work very hard to analyze rates and to not allow the industry to be damaged by bad rate-settings and changes in coverages. The proper way for people in the industry to deal with such matters is by adhering to the laws, rules, and regulations of the applicable states and within industry associations where such matters may be discussed in private without giving the industry unnecessary black eyes. Ethics is very high on the list in the insurance industry, and we don't want to lose the people's trust. That said, the industry is not perfect; but what industry is?

For our part, we believe in strong regulations and strong regulators.

We welcome your comments and ask you to keep in mind that we cannot and will not reply in any way or ways where any insurance commissioner could rightly say we've violated the law of the given state.

We are allowed to share rating-bureau data/reports and industry-consultant opinions but make clear here that those opinions are theirs and do not necessarily reflect our position.

Subscribe